Artists Uri Aran, Oded Avramovsky, Marianne Berenhaut, Max Ernst, Avner Ben Gal, Noa Glazer, George Grosz, I. S. Kalter, Talia Keinan, Martin Kippenberger, Harel Luz, Roy Menachem Markovich, Lee Nevo, Tchelet Ram, Ariel Schlesinger, Shay-Lee Uziel
Date 21.05.22 - 31.07.22
Curator Naama Arad, I. S. Kalter and Eran Nave. Developed in collaboration with CCA Tel Aviv-Yafo
Venue Dortmunder Kunstverein, Dortmund, Germany
Text Rebekka Seubert
All images Courtesy of the artist and Dortmunder Kunstverein. Photo: Jens Franke
Chapter 1 was shown at the CCA Tel Aviv-Yafo, and took a critical look at the idea of art as something ‘produced’. Chapter 2 at Dortmunder Kunstverein examines the role of artists whose present is marked by the disenchantment that professionalisation, corporate branding and its architectures have left in the individual’s sense of agency since early modernity. The world began to accelerate increasingly in last third of the 20th century: densified inner cities leave little room for individual expression; the time economy of digitalisation is optimising global effectiveness, creating not less but more work for some and none for others. Structures of capital and power are consolidating.
The exhibition takes place in the shell of the new premises of Dortmunder Kunstverein, which were formerly used as an insurance office. Artists and insurance offices are joined in a Kafkaesque love-hate relationship that exemplifies social developments – but also awakens ambivalent memories of bureaucratic coldness or of the predictability and stability that such places still emanate. Through digitalization and the pandemic, vacant office space increasingly represents a turning point: the ruins of the early 2000s office architecture now provides a space to look at the world in its status quo, to order it, to contextualise it. Rather than exaggerating and overwhelming, the sober setting of this backdrop allows the art to appear incidental, giving it a chance to reclaim its autonomy outside the spectacle.
The clock by Lee Nevo (*1984), with its somewhat ageing design, its hands pushing a mountain of cigarette stubs around, or the wooden computer by Shay-Lee Uziel (*1978), in which a rabbit made of spat-out sunflower-seed shells perches on a miniature table, can both be seen as homages to slowing down – the artists’ response to the efficiency machines of digitalisation. As the drawing of a photographic self-portrait after a shower, the work by Dortmund-born Martin Kippenberger (1953–1997), probably from the year 1973/4 and exhibited here for the first time, is the equivalent to a media doubling of memory. The drawings by Oded Avramowsky (*1956), integrated into office tracts and furniture, bring about a conflict-ridden encounter between rationality and dream. And the “Bread Library” (2020/22), by Uri Aran (*1977), which reproduces the Latin alphabet in carefully sorted block letters, is a loavely collection of utensils for the production of text. The work asks how everyday activities can be used to produce meaning. The letters can notionally stand for all kinds of sentences: poetic, bureaucratic, objective, academic, emotional, personal.
Plants bleached with cleaning fluid in the work of Tchelet Ram (*1982), a textile sculpture filled with toxic glassbuds by Noa Glazer (*1981) or Roy Menachem Markovitch (*1979)’s modernistic sculpture made of garden hoses and cables are examples of a poetic repurposing of everyday materials in this exhibition. Markovitch’s sculpture looks something like the sketch of a sculpture in the foyer of a bank, a place where for decades artworks have been used as the symbols of power and expression of potency. This idea is underlined by the pharma company Pfizer’s Viagra pill enlarged by Harel Luz (*1979).
The ascent to the gallery on the upper floor is a transit to the level of power, and is bathed in orange light (a reference to Blade Memory I): in a carpeted room stands on oversized conference table. At one end the sculpture “La Génie de la Bastille”, by Max Ernst (1891–1976) is solitarily enthroned. On the wall hangs the 1919 lithograph “Der Mensch ist gut!”, by George Grosz (1893–1959), which reflects the urban space around the Kunstverein and shows a company of three wine-drinkers, one of whom has laid his knife on the table. Both artists were in their time part of the exhibition “Degenerate Art” (1937), and can act as points of reference for how the past operates on the present, and for the question of the place of artists in society. Perhaps to the accompaniment of that unchanging song of power to which feathers dance on a record-player in the work by Talia Keinan (*1978)? Or like the network of spider’s webs in the large-format painting by Avner Ben Gal (*1966)?
The metal branch as oil lamp by Ariel Schlesinger (*1980) heralds the atmosphere of the final space, the ‘janitor’s room’: here a work by the Belgian artist and Holocaust survivor Marianne Berenhaut (*1934) stands next to the painting Death belongs to the Realm of Faith, from the 18-part series of Living Paintings by I. S. Kalter (*1986). Berenhaut’s broom is far too big for the small dustpan. An imbalance common to the exhibition as a whole that raises questions about the toxic effects of unequal power relations in the world.